Marketing Hipster

It's the connections that matter …..

  • About Cord
  • Social Media
  • Community
  • Marketing
  • Customer Experience
  • Funny
Subscribe

Dove’s Response to Discriminating Against 50% of the Population

11 January 2007 by Cord Silverstein, 5 Comments

Thanks for stopping by! Hey, why don't you do what all the cool kids are doing and subscribe to my RSS feed? You know you want to, so go ahead, be bad, be very very bad... :) Thanks.

ObjectionI wrote a story last week about Dove’s recently launched viral play following their hugely successful viral video – Evolution. For this campaign, they are allowing users to edit and create their own video and the winner gets the commercial aired during the Academy Awards. When I looked into this further, I read in the contest rules that this contest was only open to women. I did not understand why Dove would limit the pool of involvement to just women. It honestly did not make sense to me so I sent them an email asking for an explanation.

“To whom it may concern,

I would like to know why the Dove Cream Oil Body Wash Ad Contest is only open to women? Is it right that you are discriminating against 50% of the population? I am very in touch with my feminine side you know. I would like to understand your reasoning behind this. I would appreciate a response. Thank you.

Cord Silverstein”

I just threw in the feminine line for laughs… Well, even though their responder said I would get a response in 48 hours, it took 6 days, but I finally got a response.

“Dear Cord:
We received your inquiry regarding the Dove Cream Oil Body Wash Ad Contest.

While Dove appreciates all consumers, both male and female, this particular promotional campaign is open only to women. This is legal and is a promotionally targeted decision.

Males are more than welcome to create and submit their ads, that could in turn be featured in the contest gallery, but they would not be eligible to win any prizes.

Thank you for your interest in the contest, we hope this answers your question.

Your friends at Dove.”

“Promotionally Targeted Decision”, well that clears everything up for me, how about you? :(

I keep coming back to the same question that I have asked over and over again, why? I know, their product is geared towards women, I understand that. Though it just seems like excluding men who at times shop for women as well as buys Dove’s other products does nothing except hurts your product, your brand and your company in the long run. What do you think?

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Technorati Tags: viral video, Evolution, Dove

Related posts:

  1. Dove Bans All Men From Video Contest This morning I was on YouTube when I saw an ad for Dove about a contest they are holding which...
  2. Television Executives Are Dumb Wow, is that a eye catching, attention grabbing headline or what? Geez, I guess I have to back up that...
  3. All I Want for Christmas is a Good Viral Campaign A good post on Digg about a blog that was made to look like it was two young guys who...
  4. We Cannot Be Trusted A piece of paper flew my desk today that happened to catch my eye. It was a write up for...

5 Responses to “Dove’s Response to Discriminating Against 50% of the Population”

  1. James 13 January 2007 at 7:00 pm #

    Hey, let’s do an underground academy award viral using dove body wash for MEN. Screw the award!

  2. Cord Silverstein 13 January 2007 at 7:03 pm #

    LOL, I am there James..

  3. Dawn 16 January 2007 at 7:55 pm #

    Cord-
    Please stop touching your feminine side; Ninja Turtles are supposed to be tough:-)

  4. ScottW 18 January 2007 at 2:16 pm #

    Glad to see you standing up for the rights of men everywhere. I personally like how Dove explicitly stated that their ad program was “legal”. :)

    Hope you are well.

  5. Cord Silverstein 18 January 2007 at 3:45 pm #

    Hey Scott,

    Great to hear from you… I hope you are well, we have to catch up. Thanks for coming by.


Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

CommentLuv Enabledshow more

Subscribe without commenting

  • twitter Twitter View my profile
  • linkedin Linkedin View my profile
  • posterous Posterous View my profile
  • facebook Facebook View my profile
  • friendfeed Friendfeed View my profile
  • delicious Delicious View my profile
  • stumbleupon Stumbleupon View my profile
  • youtube Youtube View my profile
  • Slideshare Slideshare View my profile
  • Skype Skype View my profile
  • Foursquare Foursquare View my profile
  • flickr Flickr View my profile

Subscribe to Marketing Hipster via Email

Enter your email address:

  • Lifestream
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags

  1. Today

      • Smith & Nephew
      • Capstrat
      • Lenovo

      Checked in 3 times.

      5h ago via Foursquare

  2. Yesterday

    1. Shared 20 Quotes For Getting Through Tough Times : All SWAGGA.com.

      1:02am via Delicious

    2. Liked 20 Quotes For Getting Through Tough Times : All SWAGGA.com.

      1:02am via StumbleUpon

    3. Posted a comment.

      6:43pm via coComment

    4. Posted a comment.

      12:28pm via coComment

    5. Checked in at Hipster House

      11:50am via Foursquare

  3. September 5th

      • Top 40 Useful Sites To Learn New Skills
      • The Wal-Mart You Dont Know
      • Worlds Largest Monopoly Game
      • Learn CSS Positioning in Ten Steps: position static relative absolute float
      • Clever Uses of Stickers in Advertising
      • 15 Web Alternatives to Popular Desktop Software
      • Why Users Fill Out Forms Faster With Top Aligned Labels | UXMovement.com
      • david hieatt & 10 lessons of a web start up

      Liked 8 websites.

      3:51am via StumbleUpon

    1. Shared 15 Web Alternatives to Popular Desktop Software.

      2:32am via Delicious

    2. Shared Who'll Catalyze Change: Us or Them? - Vineet Nayar - Harvard Business Review.

      1:25am via Delicious

      • Hipster House
      • Hipster House
      • Hipster House
      • Old Hipster House
      • Lowest Home Improvement
      • Harris Teeter

      Checked in 6 times.

      10:22pm via Foursquare

  4. September 4th

      • Hipster House
      • Trinity Lot - Carter Finley Stadium

      Checked in 2 times.

      6:39pm via Foursquare

  5. September 3rd

    1. Posted a comment.

      10:01pm via coComment

  6. September 2nd

      • McDonald's
      • Capstrat

      Checked in 2 times.

      3:01am via Foursquare

    1. Posted a comment.

      12:54am via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      11:29pm via coComment

    3. Posted a comment.

      10:26pm via coComment

    4. Posted a comment.

      9:42pm via coComment

    5. Posted a comment.

      8:38pm via coComment

  7. September 1st

      • Capstrat
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 2 times.

      3:19am via Foursquare

    1. Posted a comment.

      8:45am via coComment

    Upstream

  • An iPhone Funny
  • Amazing Video
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 1
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 2
  • Comment Spam - Your Opinion is Needed
  • Kate Catlin: I love this post - what a fun comparison! I am es...
  • lebeau: The iphone is a toy!!!!!!!!!!!...
  • Jake Bernstein: It's so true. Social media and fantasy football ar...
  • Karl Sakas: "You continually have the opportunity to reinvent ...
  • marty: Long Twitter handles. Cuts into the 140 when you r...
advertising agency-client relationship Age of Conversation art & copy Blackberry blogs brand monitoring communications Community Congressman Bob Etheridge content crisis communications customer experience Dan Hesse department of energy details engagement engaging fantasy football great work kevin smith links Listening to customers marketing oldspice online conversations Online Marketing 101 online monitoring PR search engine optimization seo Social Media social media triage southwest Sprint sweat the small stuff TED time warner cable triangle ama trust twitter Twitter fail two-way conversation video We are the world

Recognized

Twitter Feed

Recent Comments

  • Kate Catlin on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • lebeau on An iPhone Funny
  • Jake Bernstein on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • Karl Sakas on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • marty on Twitter Fails
  • Fadra on 5 Tips for the Department of Energy’s Social Media Strategy
  • Fadra on Twitter Fails
  • Cord Silverstein on Social Media and Fantasy Football

Top Commentators this Month

  • No commentators.

Photos on flickr

Blogroll

  • Andy Beal
  • Angela Connor
  • Brian McDonald
  • Capstrat Blog
  • Dan London
  • David Barbara
  • Dawn Crawford
  • Erin Lane
  • Fadra Nally
  • Garnish Bar
  • Gregg Morris
  • Jay Dolan
  • Jim Hazen
  • JP Sherman
  • Karl Sakas
  • Lydia Simmons
  • Nathan Gilliatt
  • Phil Buckley
  • Punk Rock HR
  • Rob Laughter
  • Shannon Glutting
  • Sports Underground
  • Steven Keith
  • Tom Dwyer

Archives

  • July 2010 (7)
  • June 2010 (10)
  • May 2010 (2)
  • February 2010 (2)
  • July 2009 (1)
  • June 2009 (1)
  • January 2009 (1)
  • January 2008 (4)
  • November 2007 (10)
  • September 2007 (10)
  • August 2007 (10)
  • July 2007 (33)
  • June 2007 (30)
  • May 2007 (20)
  • April 2007 (28)
  • March 2007 (43)
  • February 2007 (43)
  • January 2007 (43)
  • December 2006 (18)
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes

Copyright © Marketing Hipster 2010. All Rights Reserved.

A proud member of the WooThemes logo family