Marketing Hipster

It's the connections that matter …..

  • About Cord
  • Social Media
  • Community
  • Marketing
  • Customer Experience
  • Funny
Subscribe

Viral Video Generates ZERO Hits to Web Site

5 April 2007 by Cord Silverstein, 12 Comments

Interesting article I found via Adrants about Jonathan Schoenberg of TDA Advertising & Design. About a year ago, a video was launched on YouTube where he was lecturing a class and he proceeded to grab a students cell phone who was talking on it and smashed it to the ground. The video has gotten a lot of play and discussions online. We later found out that the whole thing was stagged and according to Schoenberg, he wanted to show the power of “disruptive communication“. Whatever….

YouTube Preview Image

What is interesting is that we now have learned that even though the video has been viewed a little under 3 million times and has almost 7000 comments, this video did not generate a single click over to the TDA Advertising web site, NOT A ONE! So what does that say about Schoenberg’s disruptive marketing?

My take is that anyone can create cheap theatrics and it might grab our attention for a short period of time, but in today’s world, just grabbing people’s attention is not enough. If you want to market a product or service, you need to truly engage with the market you covet. They need to reached on a more emotional level that causes them to take some sort of action and want to do more with your brand.

What do you think?

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Technorati Tags: YouTube, disruptive communication

Related posts:

  1. Interesting Viral Experiment Folks, I introduce you to the Erin Bracht Phone Experiment. A woman named Erin has posted a video where she...
  2. The Greatest Viral Video I Have Ever Seen I might be coming late to the party on this one. This weekend, I saw a video on YouTube by...
  3. Video Can Be Used for B2B There seems to be this belief that utilizing Web 2.0 marketing tactics like word of mouth, social media and viral...
  4. Spoiled Brat Video Actually a Viral Video I am sure many of you have seen this already. A video of a spoiled girl who gets a new...
  5. Dove Fails on YouTube Over the last month, I have written several posts about Dove and their most recent viral video venture on YouTube....

12 Responses to “Viral Video Generates ZERO Hits to Web Site”

  1. Adam Schultz 5 April 2007 at 9:17 am #

    AMEN!

    PS. Congrats on the speaking gig!

  2. Cord Silverstein 5 April 2007 at 9:25 am #

    Thanks buddy! Am I going to see you there? I need all the friends I can get….

  3. lyndonmaxewell 5 April 2007 at 11:11 am #

    The answer to that is – their ploy was over disruptive. People were too distracted with the video to bother doing anything else.

  4. Adam Schultz 5 April 2007 at 11:31 am #

    I have a meeting that afternoon in Burlington so it’s not looking great. That being said, it’s on my calendar. :) Either way, knock em dead.

  5. Jeremy 5 April 2007 at 1:13 pm #

    It could be that I’m just ignorant, but I don’t see where the connection would be from the YouTube page and the TDA website. Maybe if at the end of the clip, they showed a URL, that could drive traffic.

    Where does the expectation of click-through to ANY web property come from based on this video? If that was the goal, then this is a case of really sloppy execution.

  6. Cord Silverstein 5 April 2007 at 4:10 pm #

    Lyndon – That or maybe it was not disruptive enough? Come on, he wants to be disruptive, he should of yelled and screamed and threw a tantrum!

    Jeremy – I agree with you, but I guess based on what the guy said in Adrants, they were expecting some traffic. But I guess if they put a URL at the end of the video, everyone knew is was a fake and from an agency.

    Thanks guys.

  7. Charlie Nichols 6 April 2007 at 12:24 am #

    Um, where was the web link/mention there? Did I miss it? Not sure how they could rationally expect any traffic from that. It’s amusing, but not relevant to their business, and really had no point. I still think Will it Blend? is a great relevant video series that works… George Will from Blendtec’s comment on their results on my blog post: http://www.seven87.com/2006/12/15/your-viral-marketing-will-it-blend/#comments

    Rock on MC Silverstein!

  8. thomas dooley 6 April 2007 at 8:41 am #

    It was never meant to drive hits to our website. It was a lecture and this part of it was a gag to help the students think about viral work. The reaction on youtube was largely due to people’s feelings about cell phones in general.

  9. lyndonmaxewell 6 April 2007 at 11:39 am #

    Silverstein, Silence killed. :D That explains the actions without the words. It is more scary.

    Yea, I guess it is mid-way somewhere.

  10. Zennie 11 July 2007 at 6:15 pm #

    The video itself just shows an act. What website am I supposed to go to? Curious. It does not tell me.

  11. Cord Silverstein 11 July 2007 at 9:00 pm #

    Zennie – Yea, that’s the point.. There is no where that you are told to go. Thanks for the comment.


Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

CommentLuv Enabledshow more

Subscribe without commenting

  • twitter Twitter View my profile
  • linkedin Linkedin View my profile
  • posterous Posterous View my profile
  • facebook Facebook View my profile
  • friendfeed Friendfeed View my profile
  • delicious Delicious View my profile
  • stumbleupon Stumbleupon View my profile
  • youtube Youtube View my profile
  • Slideshare Slideshare View my profile
  • Skype Skype View my profile
  • Foursquare Foursquare View my profile
  • flickr Flickr View my profile

Subscribe to Marketing Hipster via Email

Enter your email address:

  • Lifestream
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags

  1. Today

      • Isaac Hunter's Oak City Tavern
      • Busy Bee Cafe
      • Raleigh Wide Open
      • Flying Saucer Draught Emporium
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 5 times.

      3h ago via Foursquare

  2. Yesterday

    1. Posted a comment.

      2:32am via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      1:52am via coComment

    3. Liked Brian Turnwald.

      5:30am via StumbleUpon

  3. July 30th

    1. Posted a comment.

      10:59pm via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      8:41pm via coComment

    3. Posted a comment.

      1:12pm via coComment

    4. Published Social Media and Fantasy Football.

      12:32pm via marketinghipster.com

    5. Posted a comment.

      12:11pm via coComment

  4. July 29th

      • Capstrat
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 2 times.

      11:06pm via Foursquare

  5. July 28th

      • Capstrat
      • The Pit

      Checked in 2 times.

      3:51pm via Foursquare

    1. Shared How to prototype interactive iPad applications in 30 minutes using keynote | Amir Khella.

      2:14pm via Delicious

  6. July 27th

    1. Shared Batman!.

      9:31pm via Delicious

    2. Checked in at Capstrat

      12:08pm via Foursquare

  7. July 26th

    1. Posted a comment.

      4:43am via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      4:22am via coComment

    3. Posted a comment.

      4:02am via coComment

      • Capstrat
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 2 times.

      12:45am via Foursquare

    4. Posted a comment.

      12:41am via coComment

    5. Posted a comment.

      8:32pm via coComment

    Upstream

  • An iPhone Funny
  • Amazing Video
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 1
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 2
  • Comment Spam - Your Opinion is Needed
  • marty: Long Twitter handles. Cuts into the 140 when you r...
  • Fadra: Terrific assessment of DOE. But I think this holds...
  • Fadra: Thanks for writing this. Now I don't have to. I'll...
  • Cord Silverstein: You keep telling yourself that my friend. :)...
  • RoedDog: "It would have worked, if it wasn't for those nose...
advertising agency-client relationship Age of Conversation art & copy Blackberry blogs brand monitoring communications Community Congressman Bob Etheridge content crisis communications customer experience Dan Hesse department of energy details engagement engaging fantasy football great work kevin smith links Listening to customers marketing oldspice online conversations Online Marketing 101 online monitoring PR search engine optimization seo Social Media social media triage southwest Sprint sweat the small stuff TED time warner cable triangle ama trust twitter Twitter fail two-way conversation video We are the world

Recognized

Twitter Feed

Recent Comments

  • marty on Twitter Fails
  • Fadra on 5 Tips for the Department of Energy’s Social Media Strategy
  • Fadra on Twitter Fails
  • Cord Silverstein on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • RoedDog on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • Social Media and Fantasy Football | Marketing Hipster on Count it down baby!
  • jujub on An iPhone Funny
  • Karl Sakas on What does it take to produce great work?

Top Commentators this Month

  • No commentators.

Photos on flickr

Blogroll

  • Andy Beal
  • Angela Connor
  • Brian McDonald
  • Capstrat Blog
  • Dan London
  • David Barbara
  • Dawn Crawford
  • Erin Lane
  • Fadra Nally
  • Garnish Bar
  • Gregg Morris
  • Jay Dolan
  • Jim Hazen
  • JP Sherman
  • Karl Sakas
  • Lydia Simmons
  • Nathan Gilliatt
  • Phil Buckley
  • Punk Rock HR
  • Rob Laughter
  • Shannon Glutting
  • Sports Underground
  • Steven Keith
  • Tom Dwyer

Archives

  • July 2010 (7)
  • June 2010 (10)
  • May 2010 (2)
  • February 2010 (2)
  • July 2009 (1)
  • June 2009 (1)
  • January 2009 (1)
  • January 2008 (4)
  • November 2007 (10)
  • September 2007 (10)
  • August 2007 (10)
  • July 2007 (33)
  • June 2007 (30)
  • May 2007 (20)
  • April 2007 (28)
  • March 2007 (43)
  • February 2007 (43)
  • January 2007 (43)
  • December 2006 (18)
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes

Copyright © Marketing Hipster 2010. All Rights Reserved.

A proud member of the WooThemes logo family