Marketing Hipster

It's the connections that matter …..

  • About Cord
  • Social Media
  • Community
  • Marketing
  • Customer Experience
  • Funny
Subscribe

Content Wins Over Advertisers

10 May 2007 by Cord Silverstein, 2 Comments

PC WorldI have been following an interesting saga taking place over at PC World magazine. Last week, Wired reported that “Editor-in-Chief Harry McCracken quit abruptly because the company’s new CEO, Colin Crawford, tried to kill a story about Apple and Steve Jobs.”

According to reports, PC World was writing a column that was going to only appear on their web site and not the magazine titled, “Ten Things We Hate About Apple”. It was meant as a light hearted commentary and as discussed in follow up articles was pretty much just Digg link bait because top 10 lists lists tend to drive a lot of traffic.

As it has been reported, the new CEO Colin Crawford killed the story and instructed McCracken to be be nicer to PC World’s advertisers. After the CEO was not willing to budge on this issue, McCracken immediately resigned his position with the company that he has been with for 16 years. Crawford the CEO had just taken over the CEO position less than a month ago.

Well in a surprise move, IDG, owners of PC World, have reinstated Harry McCracken as Editor-in-Chief AND removed Colin Crawford as PC World’s CEO. WOW!! I was very surprised at this move and have to take my hat off to the leaders at IDG. There is someone there that realizes that once you start editing your “unbiased” content based on who are your advertisers, you will end up losing your company’s integrity and the confidence of your readers. And once you lose your readers confidence, it is a very long and hard road back.

This is one of the few examples I know of where the creative or editorial folks won over the business people. All businesses must be focused on the bottom line, but business folks tend to look very short term and will cut their nose off just to spite their face while the creative people understand what must be done to develop long term success.

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Technorati Tags: PC World, Wired, Harry McCracken, Colin Crawford, Apple, Steve Jobs, Digg, link bait, IDG

Related posts:

  1. Question of the Day: Content Aggregators A question I have been going back and forth in my mind about is whether blogs that do nothing other...
  2. Sorry Potential Customer, We Don’t Support You I was reading an article this morning about Wal-Mart launching their movie download store. After I read the above article,...
  3. User Generated Content – Quality? Doritos ran a Superbowl contest where users could submit their own commercials and the winners commercial was played during the...
  4. Link Spammers are Stupid I guess I moved into a new echelon as the link spammers have been all over me this week adding...
  5. How to be Remarkable Seth Godin has a great post on How to be Remarkable. My personal favorite as I tend to hang on...

2 Responses to “Content Wins Over Advertisers”

  1. david barbara 10 May 2007 at 8:59 pm #

    This story is near and dear to my heart as my company is in discussions to do business with this online mag. I am certain this will play a role in who we deal with now and in the future. Kuddos to IDG and more so to Harry for the morals he has. Let’s hope this story circulates throughout the online and print mediums.


Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

CommentLuv Enabledshow more

Subscribe without commenting

  • twitter Twitter View my profile
  • linkedin Linkedin View my profile
  • posterous Posterous View my profile
  • facebook Facebook View my profile
  • friendfeed Friendfeed View my profile
  • delicious Delicious View my profile
  • stumbleupon Stumbleupon View my profile
  • youtube Youtube View my profile
  • Slideshare Slideshare View my profile
  • Skype Skype View my profile
  • Foursquare Foursquare View my profile
  • flickr Flickr View my profile

Subscribe to Marketing Hipster via Email

Enter your email address:

  • Lifestream
  • Popular
  • Comments
  • Tags

  1. Today

      • Isaac Hunter's Oak City Tavern
      • Busy Bee Cafe
      • Raleigh Wide Open
      • Flying Saucer Draught Emporium
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 5 times.

      3h ago via Foursquare

  2. Yesterday

    1. Posted a comment.

      2:32am via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      1:52am via coComment

    3. Liked Brian Turnwald.

      5:30am via StumbleUpon

  3. July 30th

    1. Posted a comment.

      10:59pm via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      8:41pm via coComment

    3. Posted a comment.

      1:12pm via coComment

    4. Published Social Media and Fantasy Football.

      12:32pm via marketinghipster.com

    5. Posted a comment.

      12:11pm via coComment

  4. July 29th

      • Capstrat
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 2 times.

      11:06pm via Foursquare

  5. July 28th

      • Capstrat
      • The Pit

      Checked in 2 times.

      3:51pm via Foursquare

    1. Shared How to prototype interactive iPad applications in 30 minutes using keynote | Amir Khella.

      2:14pm via Delicious

  6. July 27th

    1. Shared Batman!.

      9:31pm via Delicious

    2. Checked in at Capstrat

      12:08pm via Foursquare

  7. July 26th

    1. Posted a comment.

      4:43am via coComment

    2. Posted a comment.

      4:22am via coComment

    3. Posted a comment.

      4:02am via coComment

      • Capstrat
      • Hipster House

      Checked in 2 times.

      12:45am via Foursquare

    4. Posted a comment.

      12:41am via coComment

    5. Posted a comment.

      8:32pm via coComment

    Upstream

  • An iPhone Funny
  • Amazing Video
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 1
  • MyBlogLog 101 - Part 2
  • Comment Spam - Your Opinion is Needed
  • marty: Long Twitter handles. Cuts into the 140 when you r...
  • Fadra: Terrific assessment of DOE. But I think this holds...
  • Fadra: Thanks for writing this. Now I don't have to. I'll...
  • Cord Silverstein: You keep telling yourself that my friend. :)...
  • RoedDog: "It would have worked, if it wasn't for those nose...
advertising agency-client relationship Age of Conversation art & copy Blackberry blogs brand monitoring communications Community Congressman Bob Etheridge content crisis communications customer experience Dan Hesse department of energy details engagement engaging fantasy football great work kevin smith links Listening to customers marketing oldspice online conversations Online Marketing 101 online monitoring PR search engine optimization seo Social Media social media triage southwest Sprint sweat the small stuff TED time warner cable triangle ama trust twitter Twitter fail two-way conversation video We are the world

Recognized

Twitter Feed

Recent Comments

  • marty on Twitter Fails
  • Fadra on 5 Tips for the Department of Energy’s Social Media Strategy
  • Fadra on Twitter Fails
  • Cord Silverstein on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • RoedDog on Social Media and Fantasy Football
  • Social Media and Fantasy Football | Marketing Hipster on Count it down baby!
  • jujub on An iPhone Funny
  • Karl Sakas on What does it take to produce great work?

Top Commentators this Month

  • No commentators.

Photos on flickr

Blogroll

  • Andy Beal
  • Angela Connor
  • Brian McDonald
  • Capstrat Blog
  • Dan London
  • David Barbara
  • Dawn Crawford
  • Erin Lane
  • Fadra Nally
  • Garnish Bar
  • Gregg Morris
  • Jay Dolan
  • Jim Hazen
  • JP Sherman
  • Karl Sakas
  • Lydia Simmons
  • Nathan Gilliatt
  • Phil Buckley
  • Punk Rock HR
  • Rob Laughter
  • Shannon Glutting
  • Sports Underground
  • Steven Keith
  • Tom Dwyer

Archives

  • July 2010 (7)
  • June 2010 (10)
  • May 2010 (2)
  • February 2010 (2)
  • July 2009 (1)
  • June 2009 (1)
  • January 2009 (1)
  • January 2008 (4)
  • November 2007 (10)
  • September 2007 (10)
  • August 2007 (10)
  • July 2007 (33)
  • June 2007 (30)
  • May 2007 (20)
  • April 2007 (28)
  • March 2007 (43)
  • February 2007 (43)
  • January 2007 (43)
  • December 2006 (18)
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes

Copyright © Marketing Hipster 2010. All Rights Reserved.

A proud member of the WooThemes logo family